would it be possible to make them only apply to specific skills instead of an entire tree.


for instance a +1 to charge bolt skilll charm or +1 to battle orders....it doesnt warp the tree this way and no one becomes super op

edit lol and you could also control the percentage to roll or find that particular skill..........heck im wondering if maybe u could make the skill charm drop with two random skills on it..........imagine the bragging rights to +1 battle order, +1 stamina for a barb , oh and level 90 ftw

_________________
Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe." Einstein

Any man who can drive safely while kissing a pretty girl is simply not giving the kiss the attention it deserves. Einstein

I don't think that is a good move as it just encourages grinding rather than playing.

_________________
People who live in cinder block houses can throw whatever they want.

I personally like Blues idea on using soulstones, but with a twist. Make them spawn with +1-2 random class skill, and not use Heroes Reward. As they are a carry one item, this would effectively cap +skills off charms at +10. As the would be random class, there would be a need to farm them, just my thoughts.
My idea would cap skills like so:
Andy- +1-2= 2max
Duriel- +1-2= 2max
Mephy- +1-2= 2max
Diablo- +1-2= 2max
Baal- +1-2= 2max
Heart =2
Anni =1
Total 15 from charms. Currently you can get 22 or 23 skills from charms alone.

_________________
"The difference between genius and stupidity is genius has its limits" Albert Einstein

Andy and duriel are too easy to give +2, and baal to hard(to get to him, kill 5 waves also) so +3, Diablo +2 as it takes time too. BUT again that won't somehow award players who wish to play after completing everything - by farming things, just making it a must to farm these items unless you want to suck.
My opinion is remove rolling from them - you'll find/trade 15 gcs you would want after 6months. Rolling, as many said, is the only way you could get that many gcs. I can say during this ladder I found like 9-10 barb comb - I know because I never trade them or roll over, just a trophy 11 curse gcs for that matter as I use them on my summoner